Excluding SNP from TV debate proves Scotland does not matter

I am pleased to hear that UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown is going to appear in a Prime Time TV debate. Unfortunately it also appears that broadcasters are attempting to exclude the most popular party in Scotland from that debate! This simply cannot be fair and must be inconsistent with the BBC's position as a politically independent broadcaster.

The idea that Scotland's views are irrelevant to a UK parliamentary election are a direct consequence of being in an unequal union with a country ten times our size. If the fiction that Scotland and Wales do indeed share an equal place in Britain is to be maintained then the SNP and Plaid Cymru must have an equal voice in this debate. Scotland is not a part of the cozy British three party consensus and to suggest that Scotland has no say whatsoever in picking the next Prime Minister is to indirectly prove the pointless of Britain as a political concept.

Those TV channels who allow such a blatantly discriminatory situation to exist are opening themselves up to legal action. They are also hastening their abolition since they are showing themselves up to be ignorant of the Scottish national interest. In such circumstances why retain a BBC if it is prepared to entirely ignore Scotland during a UK election where for the first time ever the SNP are amongst the leading contenders?

The choice is clear. Either include the SNP Government and maintain a semblance of political democracy or ignore Scotland altogether and hasten the end of both the BBC and the British Union.

Modern TV is rubbish! Scotland can and should do better

I was watching a couple of TV dramas the other night by Dennis Potter and it occurs to me that if TV ever had a Golden age it is well over.

There are no challenging dramas today that come even close to the brilliance of Potter. It's all reality TV, news programmes (usually pretty biased and leading) or bad cop shows, bad hospital shows and shitty soap operas.

If we had control over our own broadcasting (as Labour and Lib Dems recommended in the Scottish Constitutional Convention for devolution!) we could make programmes here by local authors that reflect our people's reality here in Scotland. I don't want to watch news about mad plans to put a curfew on kids in England, I want to see strong stimulating educational interesting TV dramas, relevant documentaries and news from Scotland and I want an international perspective that nonetheless puts Scotland and Scotland's interests front and centre.

We can do a lot better. The new Scottish licence fee and a proper set of guidelines for the proper TV channels could bring our broadcasting back to the educational innovative standard that at one time the BBC and ITV were famous for.

We can definitely do better, we can't possibly do worse. When talented artistic individuals like the great John Byrne are being refused commissions by BBC Scotland to make distinctive Scottish drama it shows that something is deeply wrong. Going our own way can only make sense when British TV is so absolutely and utterly awful.